Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Retaining civic our bodies to blame: From public audits to mohalla committees, many tests and balances are indispensable


Diverse large municipal firms in the country own budgets which can very effectively be the envy of a tiny bid authorities.

A for instance is the Brinhanmumbai Municipal Company, which announced a funds of Rs 33,000 crore for 2020-2021. However the query that arises is that this — why is practically every civic facility in Mumbai in a sorry bid, with out reference to the BMC’s big funds and fine workers energy?

The answer just isn’t a long way to gaze. A signal of the problem is the most as a lot as the moment recordsdata that corporators rejected a proposal by the BMC to appoint a third-party auditor to abolish quality tests on civic works. In step with the proposal, institutions equivalent to Veermata Jijabai Technological Institute, Sardar Patel College of Engineering, College of Engineering Pune and Certification Engineers International Restricted were to be roped in to behavior the audits.

The cause cited for rejecting the proposal used to be that it could actually mean incurring further expense, and that the civic physique’s engineers are able to monitoring the criteria.

This raises a genuinely distinguished query – why aren’t such audits being applied by the Comptroller and Auditor General? Legally, the CAG has the remit to serve out such audits. It spends great time and sources auditing Central Public Sector Items and Public Financial Institutions, which could even be entirely circuitously funded by the taxpayer.

For municipal firms, the spectre of a CAG audit can mumble a pair of stage of accountability. Within the absence of such accountability, corporators and civic officers can misuse public funds with out any tests and balances.

We own considered how perfectly serviceable roads are ripped up and re-laid below ‘concretisation’ plans. A concrete dual carriageway ground is anticipated to closing 30 to 40 years but in our cities, they start deteriorating after a pair of monsoons. The advent of the monsoon causes dramatic deterioration of roads, with out reference to the large sums which could even be spent ‘repairing’ these roads.

Basically, monsoon repairs own develop into milch cows for the municipal our bodies, whereas offering runt real reduction to commuters. Building flyovers where none are indispensable is one more perennial route that is taken. How a form of us can chase on a footpath in our cities with out having to step down on to the dual carriageway to steer clear of ditches, accumulated rubbish piles, exposed cables, or overflowing drains? Even supposing all these are fortuitously missing, one will continuously gain vehicles parked on footpaths. Obviously, our civic officers reflect that footpaths are meant for every thing besides strolling! After which, they also steadily rip up and then rebuild the footpaths!

The fundamental explain is the dearth of accountability. Accountability is a indispensable in the functioning of any publicly-funded physique. In case of municipal our bodies, accountability should always start with assessing whether or not a explicit venture is a indispensable at all. This could apply to as tiny an component as re-laying a footpath, and to boot to bigger initiatives equivalent to building bridges and public structures.

In quite a bit of international locations, there is a clearly laid down stakeholder consultancy process. In diverse international locations, building plans in residential areas are placed in the public area for obtaining the views of the residents who will be tormented by the pattern. If there is substantive opposition, such plans are shelved or modified.

No such process entailing public scrutiny of plans and budgets is in plight in India. Our elected leaders judge on what is ‘factual’ for the voters.

A for instance is a ‘multi-storeyed underground car car car parking zone’ being constructed in Thane. This aged to be a playground where teenagers aged to play video games and weekend markets were held for selling farmers’ have confidence. The most effective factor used to be that this used to be an start, unpaved space, which helped rainwater percolation and drainage.

On the opposite hand, the municipal corporation as a consequence of this truth made up our minds to have confidence a multi-storeyed underground car car car parking zone there. The ground used to be fenced off and the excavation work started. This plight used to be reserved for a playground and the authorities accorded sanction for an underground car car car parking zone with out changing the unusual exhaust – the parking could be underground and the playground will be above the parking dwelling! Local residents protested, asserting that this could perchance cause waterlogging, site traffic congestion and that the plight could also turn correct into a refuge for drug peddlers and diversified anti-social system. Lastly, a native resident went to the court. Lo and seek for, the very subsequent day, a community of corporators, reducing across party lines, visited the positioning and grandly declared that such worries are counterfeit and that the underground parking facility will meet a crying public want. Following this narrate over with, the work on the venture gathered further momentum, presumably to contemporary a fait accompli when the lawful explain comes up for listening to.

In a same vein, at this very 2nd, a perfectly factual gallop surrounding the central lake in Thane metropolis has been ripped up with the talked about purpose of ‘beautifying’ it. This when the roads are in pathetic prerequisites, the bid of municipal colleges and hospitals is wicked and the municipal transport is at breaking level for want of funds!

One more case in Mumbai is of a tiny lane in a aloof residential colony. This lane, perfectly serviceable, used to be ripped up a couple of years up to now and re-laid with ‘paver blocks’ which upset the pure slope and drainage of the lane. This 300 and sixty five days, the civic physique has again issued a notification that this lane is being ‘concretised’. Here’s a tiny lane where hardly any vehicles ply besides the residents’ vehicles. The reasons are not a long way to gaze – inner most fortunes are constructed out of public works in our country.

Who will get elected and why

On this context, one desires to opt into consideration the failings in step with which corporators are elected. This creator has witnessed an election where aged voters in a low-profits dwelling were promised free journeys to nearby pilgrimage websites after which they voted overwhelmingly for a candidate who used to be not competent.

A median corporator customarily has to gain funds for the political party which offers him the tag. The form of individual could exhaust the different to line his or her pockets too. To cease such misuse of public funds, transparency in planning and execution of any venture must be constructed into the process. This could be ensured via a sturdy public session mechanism as effectively as a public audit of each venture – not merely the accounting ledgers of the corporation.

Equally, folks should always actively take part in civic existence. Step one on this route is to chase out and vote in municipal elections. This could merely work a lengthy system in the direction of guaranteeing that execrable and non-performing candidates are held to blame for the duration of the election. Also, ‘mohalla committees’, which could be given a proper feature in the session process, could be fashioned.

Within the closing diagnosis, it boils correct down to an alert citizenry which recognises that factual governance can entirely be secured via eternal vigilance and spirited engagement with civic affairs.

This text used to be first printed in Citizen Matters, a civic media online page and is republished right here with permission. (c) Oorvani Basis/Open Media Initiative.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like


Chamoli, Uttarakhand:  As rescue operation is underway at the tunnel where 39 people are trapped, Uttarakhand Director General of Police (DGP) Ashok Kumar on Tuesday said it...


India’s energy demands will increase more than those of any other country over the next two decades, underlining the country’s importance to global efforts...


Leaders from across parties bid an emotional farewell to senior Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad on his retirement from the Rajya Sabha. Mentioning Pakistan...


Tehran:  A member of the armed forces is suspected of involvement in last November’s assassination near Tehran of Iran’s top nuclear scientist Mohsen Fakhrizadeh,...