Press "Enter" to skip to content

A tale of three books and a reluctant whistleblower: How Asad Durrani took on the Pakistan Military

‘The pen is mightier than the sword” is the adage we were taught true from our faculty days. After sheathing the sword, this used to be as a minimum my most optimistic weapon. I’d had an though-provoking occupation — heading the Pakistan Military and the Inter-Services and products Intelligence, as the icing on the cake — and then my retirement from the militia used to be adopted by some diplomatic brushes. That helped ravishing-tune my observations and provide enough substance for my first e book, Pakistan Adrift. It used to be revealed by Hurst UK in September 2018 — obviously stating the Pakistan Military in dispatches, with all its ravishing traditions and some traits got by the broader social milieu.

In the intervening time, I stumbled upon one other writing mission. In a phrase-two assembly I met Amarjeet Singh Dulat who had headed R&AW at the flip of the century. Apart from being comfy with himself, it used to be his immense skills in Kashmir that made our exchanges extra priceless. In consequence of this truth, we collectively wrote papers on intelligence and Kashmir and had them revealed on public boards. Quickly thereafter, he got right here out with a e book, Kashmir: The Vajpayee Years. His frankness and namely his empathy with Kashmiris might maybe presumably well additionally have earned him some criticism at home, nonetheless the e book used to be properly received in Pakistan.

These were your complete actual the the rationalization why, when Dulat instructed that we might maybe presumably well additionally write a e book together, I agreed. If any dilapidated heads of intelligence from chronically opposed international locations ever undertook this form of project, I attain no longer know; nonetheless indeed it had by no come been carried out on the subcontinent. Moreover, reminded over and over that Pakistan used to be no longer getting its tale all over, I believed it used to be most intelligent carried out by a e book that used to be probably to get waves, presumably even kick up a storm. With the support of a moderator it took us about two years to attain this project that dealt with a differ of points affecting India-Pakistan members of the family — reasonably advanced, to connect aside it mildly.

This e book, The Leer Chronicles: RAW, ISI and the Illusion of Peace, used to be revealed by HarperCollins and launched in Delhi on 23 Can also, 2018. I used to be reasonably overjoyed with our joint effort because it projected Pakistan’s regional policies in an cheap light. And then an astronomical gathering — Dr Manmohan Singh, the dilapidated Top Minister of India; the as of late retired vice-president Hamid Ansari; the evergreen Dr Farooq Abdullah; two dilapidated Union ministers; a nationwide security handbook; two diverse dilapidated intelligence heads and a galaxy of the Indian intellectual elite — permitted the main recommendation of the e book: India to address the Kashmir subject in cooperation with Pakistan.

It did ruffle about a feather in India, nonetheless the noise it generated in Pakistan used to be deafening.

It took me reasonably a whereas to get sense of this lunacy. Six days after the open, I used to be summoned to the GHQ, ostensibly to defuse this cacophony. It didn’t sound too ominous nonetheless I mute might maybe presumably well additionally no longer rule out the risk of getting quizzed on ‘writing with out clearance’. In all likelihood because, besides treason and treachery, this used to be one accusation that used to be bandied about the loudest on the media. Revealing secrets and suggestions might maybe presumably well additionally have been one other likely price, though reasonably hard to stick.

Each and every the points were useless to claim raised, nonetheless quick dropped because many books had been written with out permission and no secrets and suggestions will probably be found in The Leer Chronicles. Then once more, when the panelstarted questioning my views as given within the e book, I had reasons to scent a rat. No longer most optimistic because I had steadily expressed them in writing or in public — and used to be as a minimum entitled to them — nonetheless additionally because about a of their objections were both extraneous, for example, ‘I took extra condo within the e book than my co-creator’; or factually wrong, treasure ‘whereas I had slated about a of our actions, Dulat used to be extra evasive’.

At the least no doubt one of them used to be reasonably upset that the racket created by the e book received Nawaz Sharif off the hook. To refresh our reminiscence, the dilapidated high minister had as of late mocked the establishment for dragging its ft on the Mumbai 2008 fear attacks and used to be squarely within the crosshairs of the media, which now shifted onto me. It used to be most optimistic a formality. The resolution to motivate a court of inquiry and keep my name on the Exit Alter List (ECL) had already been taken. And I used to be instructed, for the third time in lower than 24 hours, no longer to be in contact to the media that within the meanwhile, prodded by the ISPR, used to be firing on all cylinders.

A surreal scenario, nonetheless it used to be rationalised as the navy’s desire to be considered as even-handed: ‘No longer sparing even one from its non-public fraternity, suspected to have violated some amorphous code’. The Courtroom of Inquiry held about a sessions in June and July. I asked them below which Act it had been constituted, and what used to be I accused of. “That might maybe presumably well properly be made up our minds after the inquiry,” used to be all I will probably be educated. It reminded me of the Queen of Hearts from Alice in Wonderland: ‘Dangle him first, we are succesful of strive him later’. All over once more, the questions were largely on the contents of the e book — steadily twisting or distorting the text.

My criticism of Kargil and the Lal Masjid Operations, even supposing carried out publicly within the previous, offered them the mandatory ammunition. Some consultants invited to commentary on the e book exposed the mala fide intent. Just a few glaring examples:
• ‘The E book had given away high-secrets and suggestions’. Nobody might maybe presumably well additionally name even a straightforward secret.
• ‘It had demoralised the navy’. Though no longer steadily someone had read it.
• ‘R&AW used to be extra than overjoyed with this e book’. Apart from how one assessed the happiness or the unhappiness of a international secret carrier, R&AW used to be no longer going to be overjoyed with a e book by which no doubt one of its dilapidated heads criticised many an Indian policy — particularly on Kashmir.
• Definitely one of them used to be stunning enough to concede that he had been tasked most optimistic to steal holes.

It used to be mute a actually priceless remark because within the kill it helped me label their accurate motives. One other session with the first panel on the alternative hand left me reasonably confused. The Leer Chronicles had advertised the forthcoming e book, Pakistan Adrift, by which I had given my views from a certified privileged standpoint. I used to be asked to produce its script, which I fortunately did, because even supposing about a institutional deficits were mentioned, the e book offered a various tale; largely loyal. In August, I used to be called once more and instructed that the e book’s e-newsletter must be stopped and the GHQ used to be ready to compensate the publisher for the price and effort already invested.

The substances that had ostensibly upset them — the militia’s involvement within the accurate-property industry; some ostentatious habits that had infested the senior ranks; and heart-broken generalship in wars versus actual performances by junior officers and the troopers — were so unremarkable that no longer steadily an eyebrow used to be raised when the e book finally got right here out. It mute extracted a cost. No publicity used to be permitted and tons of of libraries that typically would have offered this e book, didn’t. I believe that someone received scared that Pakistan Adrift had the alternative of turning actual into a most in vogue read.

In early September, I asked the GHQ to have my name far off from the ECL, because I used to be invited to a convention in Afghanistan — and desired to confer with with my grandchildren. When there used to be no response, I went to the court. Comments received from GHQ, summarised below, affirmed that it wasn’t constrained by the finer points of law:
• The Act quoted below which I used to be investigated, didn’t apply in this case.
• That I had co-authored a “controversial e book” with a dilapidated head of R&AW. It’s no longer prohibited below any law, and as a minimum what actual used to be a e book if it didn’t generate a tiny controversy, leave aside the truth that it used to be the GHQ that made it controversial.
• I had delved in matters of nationwide security. Neatly, that’s exactly what I used to be doing for the previous 25 years — additionally within the Indian and Pakistani defence journals.
• In consequence of a 2nd e book, the GHQ used to be taking into consideration of accelerating the scope of the inquiry and used to be going by considerations getting the witnesses from diverse international locations. No such efforts were made and within the very subsequent listening to their council conceded that the name on the ECL used to be most optimistic to guarantee that my availability for the inquiry — which had now been done.
• There used to be mute no reduction. The court handed the buck to the Ministry of Interior, which for nearly 21 months has dilly-dallied.

I finally received some clue what might maybe presumably well have led the powers-that-be to govern this direction of.

Rapidly after assuming office, the incumbent Chief of Military Staff (COAS) received portion of the Asghar Khan Case linked to Aslam Beg and me transferred to the GHQ. In November and December 2018, one other panel grilled me for 2 months to notify — what I had steadily mentioned within the Supreme Courtroom — that sooner than the 1990 elections, Beg used to be a actually valuable cog within the loop when money used to be dished out to a pair politicians. I offered them a duplicate of his April 1994 voice by which he had admitted that in September 1990 (Beg used to be the navy chief at the time), he had salvage PKR 140 million from Younus Habib and handed them on to the ISI.

I additionally handed over copies of Habib’s affidavits, and instructed the panel that extra proof might maybe presumably well be offered if Beg, the first respondent within the Supreme Courtroom’s judgment, used to be produced for awful-examination. I by no come heard from them ever since — nearly two years now. I ponder it be because Beg and Qamar Javed Bajwa were commissioned within the identical unit, 16 Baluch. That additionally outlined why the agencies had started hovering around my condo after Bajwa grew to alter into the navy chief — and that used to be long sooner than someone had even heard of The Leer Chronicles. In January 2018 (the e book used to be mute nowhere on the horizon), I used to be instructed the night sooner than an event within the Military Auditorium — for which I used to be invited and had consented — to face down because I had no longer been granted security clearance.

Earlier than that, Similar old Mahmood Durrani, inaccurate to be me, used to be additionally denied entry to an navy characteristic. He rang up Bajwa and the combine-up used to be taken care of in rapid time. At this stage, I might maybe presumably well additionally have yelled “Eureka” for having found the foundation space off of my predicament. But when almost at the moment after getting the ECL case safely buried in a ministerial graveyard, the GHQ sent me a letter that the Courtroom of Inquiry had found me guilty of shameful misconduct and therefore my pension used to be revoked, I had reasons to ponder that something far extra atrocious than the regimental loyalty of their chief used to be at stake. No punishment will also be administered after a Courtroom of Inquiry, unless it used to be adopted by a abstract of evidence or a display-space off seek.

Beg’s displeasure might maybe presumably well additionally have motivated his unit officer to derive my international breeze banned, nonetheless no longer to so blatantly violate all felony guidelines and conventions. I had already dominated out writing The Leer Chronicles as the raison d’être of this theatre of the absurd. At the least, when no particular provisions will also be found, there were continuously Acts that treasure a joker in a pack will also be invoked to compare around an undesirable neck. The subject perceived to be that besides for an uncommon price, no longer appropriate right here by a long shot — someone who had retired decades support might maybe presumably well additionally most optimistic be tried in a civil court. And in this case, there used to be a actual likelihood of acquittal.

It can presumably well be confirmed in an initiate court that the e book did no damage to our interests.

Truly there might maybe be a stunning alternative of senior officers, about a mute in carrier, who conceded that it used to be very loyal. I therefore had to undercover agent some diverse blast from the previous, so extreme that it had Bajwa near gunning for me soon after taking up, and at an opportune time — in this case, the “controversial e book” providing one — pull out all stops and dawdle for the jugular. And factual when I predominant it, I too received my lucky damage. A properly-wisher of mine unintentionally met someone who used to be Similar old Ashfaq Parvez Kayani’s true hand man at the time of the Abbottabad outrage.

When asked what the subject used to be with The Leer Chronicles, the man went purple within the face and mentioned: “Similar old Durrani must not have written about the Osama bin Laden incident”. So noteworthy now started falling in attach aside. I used to be attending an Afghanistan convention in Abu Dhabi at the time of the raid. Though I knew nothing previous the press experiences, I mute agreed to consume portion in a clear episode of the BBC‘s Exhausting Focus on — since the diverse participants were a retired British navy chief and a dilapidated deputy nationwide security handbook from the US. In the self-assumed role of the sole defender of Pakistan, I gave my most intelligent journey to what might maybe presumably well have occurred: “With out our support the raid might maybe presumably well additionally no longer have been tried — nonetheless we denied any role due to the political considerations”.

Again home I penned my thesis for which I had received plenty of accolades from some revered colleagues, and received it revealed in The Inform Tribune. Rapidly thereafter one other halt friend of Kayani’s reached out to me and mentioned: “If someone along with your intelligence background differed from the expedient version on so comfy a subject; would no longer it be taken as internal knowledge?” Now, it factual so occurred that many treasure me were going around broadcasting their respective versions. The unhurried Hameed Gul believed that Osama used to be no longer even indicate within the raided condo; and in accordance with Beg, he used to be brought there useless to be handed over.

Since this gentleman might maybe presumably well additionally by no come be suspected of any profound reflections, I didn’t consume his argument severely.

Perchance I might maybe presumably well additionally mute have, because when I subsequent gave the identical overview there used to be a global commotion. It used to be a high-profile event on Al Jazeera, Head to Head with Mehdi Hassan, recorded in February 2015 in Oxford. With an viewers of around 400, most of them equipped with smartphones, as soon as I talked about our likely support, a tsunami of messages used to be launched into our on-line world: “A dilapidated head of the ISI has conceded that Pakistan used to be harbouring the enviornment’s most wanted terrorist.” Again home, my incumbent successor summoned me nonetheless wasn’t reasonably happy with my rationalization.

It took one other three years till the inquiry on The Leer Chronicles and the accompanying hullabaloo within the media, offered some solutions. The quiz by Kayani’s friend that sounded silly when first asked seven years support, used to be propagated so steadily, both internal and outside the GHQ, that it wasn’t hard for me to infer that it used to be planted by someone unhappy with my thesis — no longer because treasure Gul’s or Beg’s, my consume used to be diverse from the expedient myth; nonetheless because I used to be no longer most optimistic speaking a pair of probably cooperation, nonetheless additionally a pair of likely deal.

My assessments were bolstered when in some unspecified time in the future of the inquiry, an interrogator inadvertently indicated that we had some inkling of the raid — and in an formally-backed work, the creator concluded that we most in vogue ‘incompetence over complicity’. Cooperation in a single derive or the diverse — from providing knowledge about the cell numbers to having a gaze the diverse components — had been talked about by so many and so steadily that it didn’t appear to be a mountainous deal. But I attain no longer pick if someone else ever instructed that we additionally might maybe presumably well have made a deal. In the above-mentioned Al Jazeera episode, I did dispute that if we had someone treasure Osama, we must not have handed him over with out a quid educated quo — in utterly different locations even instructed that in return we might maybe presumably maybe properly have asked the American citizens to derive the hell out of our space.

And in some unspecified time in the future of the inquiry, when someone mentioned that the mere thought that we’d have made offers in this industry used to be inappropriate, I might maybe presumably well additionally sense that some physique up there used to be terribly scared that I’d know extra about it — and had reasons to actually feel nervous. I now had a subject — what to attain with my discovery? I might maybe presumably well additionally dawdle to the court, and indeed had a actual likelihood to notify that the GHQ had acted unlawfully. I used to be no longer charged below any Act; punishment inflicted with out trial used to be a blatant violation of principles; and since I attain no longer near below the Pakistan Military Act, the GHQ had no jurisdiction to prosecute me, besides below provisions no longer relevant in this case.

The bias against me too used to be evident.

Bajwa’s boys got right here for me noteworthy sooner than The Leer Chronicles made its appearance — and his regimental ancestor (Beg) who had been changing his statements within the Supreme Courtroom and dumping his particles on me, used to be spared any awful-examination. Or no longer it is additionally likely to produce evidence that in some unspecified time in the future of the investigations of this sordid affair, a defamation advertising campaign against me used to be orchestrated by the ISPR. Brooding about on the alternative hand that the courts will probably be influenced on minor accounts — treasure the elimination of my name from the ECL — and couldn’t even open big proceedings on the revocation of pension for 18 months — a case by which the COAS used to be the main accused — had no likelihood of a stunning trial, or presumably even of acceptance for a listening to.

I mute might maybe presumably maybe remark this risk as a subject of true. Taking the story to the press might maybe presumably well additionally no doubt derive plenty of a rumpus. But there used to be continuously the risk of a backlash, and the desired agree with will probably be contained by actual media administration. Or, one might maybe presumably well additionally write but one other e book. Whichever route I took, it entailed risk to life and limb. Truly it had to be assumed that the GHQ would hit support. And then there used to be additionally the risk of an external reaction. On the Osama incident, the credibility of the US used to be on the line. If I mute made up our minds to remark one or extra of these alternatives, I actually have a motive price your complete probably cost. For the previous over two years, I actually have lived below the shadow of an alleged misdeed: Co-authoring a e book with a dilapidated intelligence chief from India.

Though no longer proscribed by any civil or militia law, I might maybe presumably well additionally have mute been prosecuted for committing an undesirable act. But since the provisions of the Pakistan Military Act appropriate to someone who retired decades support, didn’t duvet this case, the GHQ worn diverse come to defame me, restrict my rights of free speech and mosey, and inflict an illegal penalty. It did so because in an initiate court it might maybe maybe probably probably presumably well be confirmed that its chief carried a bias that predated the e book. Clearing my name used to be therefore valuable — nonetheless no longer as valuable as bringing to light a extreme flaw, which if no longer corrected, can gravely damage a sacred institution.

Bajwa’s desire to get life hard for me on behalf of his Baluchi predecessors (Kayani too belongs to this group and used to be once Bajwa’s boss) will probably be understandable, nonetheless what is noteworthy extra disconcerting is that so many within the senior hierarchy, civil and navy, fell in line when an navy chief so desired. I’m mindful of the energy of the gun and in Pakistan, of the special attach aside its wielders skills. But that this energy will probably be worn for lower than chic capabilities — to pressurise the press and arm-twist the judiciary — though general knowledge, had to be affirmed by someone treasure me for posterity.

I therefore opted to write a e book. Honour Among Spies, though a work of fiction, does address about a events that truly occurred. The predominant procedure used to be two-fold. Apart from about a of my dilapidated colleagues, many from right by the institution too were searching to defuse the subject. An agreement used to be ready to derive my name far off from the ECL and the pension restored. In return I used to be to concede that I had no longer anticipated that the appears of The Leer Chronicles might maybe presumably well additionally space off the reaction that it did. But when I refused to abstain from attending conferences at home or in a foreign country, the diagram used to be keep on ice.

No subject the penalties therefore, a message had to be out that this institution of our last resort must be saved from turning actual into a instrument within the palms of a extremely optimistic few.

And since my guess about the Osama episode perceived to be nearer to the label than the expedient version — both the Pakistani and the American — I wanted the subject that had wrecked big humiliation on Pakistan, to be extra earnestly investigated. I used to be mute reluctant to write about the accurate events, nonetheless my hand used to be compelled by a actually damning paper handed over by the Ministry of Defence’s council within the latest listening to on the ECL subject.

Apart from “spilling secrets and suggestions and delving in nationwide security” — both points dealt with earlier in this myth — I used to be accused of “being affiliated with R&AW since 2008”. Honour Among Spies too used to be presupposed to have been supported by opposed aspects. How these expenses will probably be confirmed within the court is no longer for me to have interaction nonetheless even a layman might maybe presumably well additionally keep a query to why no action used to be taken against me ever since the suspected hyperlinks were “found” — or used to be the chargesheet ready as a reaction to my fictional myth. Indeed, I will must protect the substance of the three books — and additionally display that in this digital age, the geographical location of publishing condo didn’t subject. The comfy copies will probably be found everywhere in the attach aside the globe sooner than one can dispute “copyright”.

I’m succesful of additionally produce evidence that many publishers within the UK and USA were reluctant to print my novel, presumably due to the the Osama bit. The GHQ paper additionally argued that if the ECL used to be removed, I’d once more be attending conferences in a foreign country. Neatly, in instances of COVID-19, I’m doing it from home and additionally giving my views, even these extreme of the civil and navy management — as is my true below the Structure. This indicate day, the restriction on my breeze in a foreign country is most optimistic preventing me from visiting my granddaughters. Since someone within the press might maybe presumably well additionally access these grave accusations from the court and dawdle to town with them, I had to pre-empt and get my version public.

Moreover, I produce no longer have any thought how the GHQ would phrase-up on such extreme allegations. I actually have therefore instructed my attorneys to originate appropriate factual proceedings to ban the authorities from taking any illegal action against me till such time the courts have interaction otherwise.

*Names don’t have any longer been taken unless fully mandatory, because one day the subject might maybe presumably well additionally want to be taken to a court of law.

PS: Right by the early days of this disaster when the media hounds had been unleashed on me, I used to be reminded of a alternative of quotes on barking dogs. I had no thought at the time that one day these howling herds would support me unravel no doubt one of many most intelligent riddles of our instances. In the reminiscence of Sherlock Holmes, I nearly titled this portion “the dogs that barked”.

The creator is a retired three-big name noxious customary within the Pakistan Military and served as the director-customary of the Inter-Services and products Intelligence and dilapidated director-customary of the Pakistan Military’s Armed forces Intelligence. He is currently a commentator, speaker and creator

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply